Respondent
Theme
Collective Investment Institutions in the Context of Global Financial Instability
Defence Date
Annotation
Dissertation is devoted to the complex research of the causes, patterns of CII
development, processes of transformation in the conditions of global financial in-
stability and the development of practical recommendations for the cultivation of CII
in Ukraine, taking into account the world experience.
The thesis analyzes theoretical basis of the CII functioning especially the
researches devoted to efficient market hypothesis and influence of these research
results on the transformation of practices and forms of organization of the CII,
especially in the field of index investing. Spreading of index investment strategies
and possible consequences of popularization of such an investment strategy for CII
and stock market is estimated. Particular attention is paid to the relationship of
pension systems and CII. Specific properties of exchange-traded funds comparing to
traditional funds, organization and development in various regions of the world are
comprehensively analyzed.
The differences between synthetic and traditional exchange-traded funds are
studied and classified. Reasons of popularity of synthetic scheme in Europe
comparing to USA is explained by regulatory differences. It is also empirically
proven, using a sample of 35 equity ETFs traded at the Swiss Stock Exchange and
tracking error estimation in four different ways, that both traditional and synthetic
ETFs have significant tracking errors. The findings also proves that, synthetic ETFs
have higher tracking errors than physical, though this is contrary to popular opinion.
Additionally, such factors as expense ratio, number of securities in the benchmark
and type of replication for all estimation methods are estimated in their influence on
tracking error. The results suggest that tracking errors are influenced by expense
ratio, number of securities in the benchmark and type of replication. Average daily
trading volume doesn’t influence dependent variables except for one tracking error
estimation method. Risks of financial stability of massive spreading of synthetic
ETFs are classified and the challenges posed by ETFs development on financial
community are revealed.
Thesis analyzes Ukrainian stock market as a functioning environment of CII,
identifies main problems and assesses the current state of CII in the national market,
proposes framework recommendations aimed to improve the stock market in general
and conditions for CII in particular. These recommendations are combined and
classified in such way: – improvement of the institutional framework and macro-
economic situation: improvement of the protection of property rights, corporatization
of public enterprises, and further privatization, improvement of the financial edu-
cation of citizens, fiscal stabilization, inflation targeting and exchange rate libera-
lization; – measures to improve the stock market and CII in particular: expanding
supply of financial assets by double rotation, enlargement offers of financial assets
through access to foreign securities, legislative introduction of the accumulative
pension system; – areas of work for the private sector: privatization lobbying,
participation in privatization, improvement of corporate governance; participation in
the campaigns; involvement in double rotation; facilitating access to the stock market
for investors.
Keywords: collective investment institutions, CII, investment funds, exchan-
ge-traded funds, ETFs, stock market, financial stability risks.